I have been using the Windows Media Center Edition (MCE) for several years and have had great success with it. My home built Home Theater PC (HTPC) was beefy and decked out (for the time). All in all it was nice. Then came our plasma HDTV which changed everything. I had to upgrade from 2 internal video capture cards to use 2 Comcast HD set top boxes. But to get HD out of it I had to use 1394, bubble gum and baling wire. It was as hacky as it got, but it worked — usually.

Several years later I finally broke down and purchased a Vista MCE. It’s a very nice Velocity Micro box and decked out with 2 internal cablecard tuners and a beefy video card. Again, it is very nice. Very nice, until I tried using my XBox 360 as a Media Extender.Long ago I purchased a Linksys media center extender so that I could watch news, movies and, of course, Law & Order while on the elliptical machine. The problem was that once we started recording HD I was screwed. The Linksys not only could not handle the bandwidth required for HD over its wireless network, but the machine itself couldn’t handle it even if it was wired directly with a cat 5 cable. Sad, very, very sad.